top of page

Welcome to Your Path to Success:
How to Start an Independent Insurance Agency

Starting an independent insurance agency can be one of the most rewarding and profitable business ventures you embark on. With the right knowledge and tools, you can achieve success in this thriving industry. Join thousands of Independent insurance agents who took the leap to own their own businesses.
How to start an Independent Insurance agency join other insurance agents
How to start an Independent Insurance agency - hustle

You can Be Your Own Boss

As an independent insurance agent, you have the freedom to run your business your way. You decide your hours, choose your clients, and set your goals.

High Income Potential

The insurance industry is incredibly lucrative. According to the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA), independent agents earn an average annual income of over $120,000. 

Growing Market Demand

The demand for insurance services continues to rise. The U.S. insurance market is expected to reach $1.4 trillion by 2025, offering ample opportunities for new agents to thrive.

Diverse Product Offerings

Independent agents have access to a wide range of insurance products. This diversity allows you to meet the varied needs of your clients, enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Starting an independent insurance agency allows you to be your own boss, enjoy high income potential, and meet the growing demand for insurance services. Independent agents have the freedom to offer a diverse range of products, ensuring clients get the best coverage options available. The insurance industry is expanding, making it an ideal time to start your own agency and tap into a market expected to reach $1.4 trillion by 2025.

Why Start an Independent Insurance Agency?

Independent vs. Captive Insurance Agents: 
Why Choose Independent Status Over Captive Status?

Choosing to become an independent insurance agent offers several significant advantages over working as a captive agent for companies like State Farm or Farmers Insurance. Here are some reasons why going independent is better:

Product Variety

Independent agents can offer insurance products from multiple carriers, giving clients more options to choose from. This flexibility allows you to tailor policies to better meet the needs of your clients, resulting in higher customer satisfaction and loyalty. In contrast, captive agents are limited to selling products from a single carrier, which may not always be the best fit for their clients.


With access to multiple carriers, independent agents can shop around for the best rates and coverage options for their clients. This ability to provide competitive pricing can be a significant advantage in attracting and retaining clients. Captive agents, on the other hand, can only offer the rates and products of their single carrier, which may not always be competitive in the market.

and Flexibility

As an independent agent, you have the freedom to run your business as you see fit. You can set your own hours, choose your clients, and determine your business strategies. This level of autonomy is not available to captive agents, who must adhere to the policies and procedures of their parent company.

Client Service

Independent agents can build stronger, more personal relationships with their clients by providing unbiased advice and a wider array of insurance solutions. This personalized service can lead to higher client retention rates and more referrals. Captive agents, restricted by the offerings of their parent company, may struggle to provide the same level of tailored service.

The Essential Steps:
How to Start Your Independent Insurance Agency

Embarking on the journey to start your own independent insurance agency involves careful planning and strategic action. By following these essential steps, you can establish a successful and profitable agency that meets the needs of your clients and stands out in the competitive insurance market.

Step 01 

Research and Planning

  • Market Research: Understand the needs of your target market. Identify potential clients, assess the competition, and analyze market trends.

  • Business Plan: Create a comprehensive business plan outlining your business goals, target market, marketing strategies, and financial projections. This plan will serve as your roadmap to success.

Step 02

Legal and Licensing Requirements

  • Licensing: Each state has its own licensing requirements for insurance agents. You will need to pass a licensing exam and fulfill any continuing education requirements.

  • Legal Structure: Decide on the legal structure of your business (e.g., sole proprietorship, partnership, LLC). Register your business with the appropriate state authorities.

Step 03

Financial Preparation

  • Initial Capital: Determine how much capital you will need to start your agency. This includes costs for office space, equipment, marketing, and operational expenses.

  • Funding Options: Explore funding options such as personal savings, small business loans, or investors.

Step 04

Choose Your Carriers

  • Insurance Carriers: Partner with multiple reputable insurance carriers or join an insurance alliance such as Pacific Crest Services to gain access to multiple carriers. A diverse portfolio of carriers allows you to offer a wide range of insurance products and competitive pricing to your clients.

  • Contracts and Agreements: Negotiate contracts and agreements with insurance carriers to ensure you have favorable terms and conditions.

Step 05

Set Up Your Office

  • Office Space: Choose a suitable location for your office. Consider factors such as accessibility, visibility, and cost.

  • Technology and Systems: Invest in technology and systems that streamline your operations. This includes agency management software, CRM systems, and communication tools.

Step 06

Marketing and
Client Acquisition

  • Branding: Develop a strong brand identity. This includes a professional logo, business cards, and marketing materials.

  • Online Presence: Create a professional website that highlights your services and expertise. Optimize your website for search engines to attract potential clients.

  • Digital Marketing: Utilize digital marketing strategies such as social media marketing, email marketing, and content marketing to reach your target audience.

  • Networking: Attend industry events, join local business organizations, and network with potential clients and referral partners.

Step 07

Building Your Team

  • Hiring Staff: As your agency grows, consider hiring additional staff to help with sales, customer service, and administrative tasks.

  • Training and Development: Invest in ongoing training and development for yourself and your team to stay updated with industry trends and best practices.

Step 08

Providing Excellent Customer Service

  • Client Relationships: Build strong relationships with your clients by providing excellent customer service. Respond promptly to inquiries, offer personalized solutions, and follow up regularly.

  • Feedback and Improvement: Seek feedback from your clients and continuously improve your services based on their input.

Bonus Step

Embrace Technology
and Innovation

  • Digital Tools: Leverage the latest technology to improve efficiency and client service. Use digital tools for client management, policy tracking, and communication. 

  • Join an Insurance agent Alliance: By joining an alliance such as Pacific Crest Services you streamline your operations, access hundred of carriers, enhance your accounting and commissions , and keep you competitive in the market.

  • Continuous Learning: Stay updated with technological advancements in the insurance industry. Participate in webinars, conferences, and training sessions focused on innovation and technology.

High Earnings

According to industry reports, independent insurance agents earn an average of over $120,000 per year. Top-performing agents can earn significantly more.

Growing Industry

The U.S. insurance industry is projected to grow steadily, with the market expected to reach $1.4 trillion by 2025.

Customer Loyalty

Insurance is a necessity for individuals and businesses, leading to high customer retention rates. Satisfied clients often provide referrals, further boosting your income potential.

Insurance Carriers

Choosing the right insurance carriers is crucial to the success of your independent insurance agency. To offer the best service to your clients, it's essential to partner with both preferred carriers and niche carriers. Preferred carriers are well-known and reputable companies that provide a wide range of insurance products, ensuring your clients have access to comprehensive coverage options. Niche carriers, on the other hand, specialize in specific types of insurance, allowing you to cater to unique needs within personal and commercial lines of business. By combining these carriers, you can provide tailored solutions that meet the diverse needs of your clients, enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Success Stories

"Starting my independent insurance agency was a game-changer. With Pacific Crest Services' guidance, I quickly established my business and now enjoy a thriving client base." - Janet D.

"Making a profit is the reason I became a business owner. Pacific Crest Services helped me realize all the opportunity I was losing out on as a Captive Allstate agent. It never seemed to matter how large I grew that agency, I always struggled to turn a profit. Now that I'm partnered with Pacific Crest Services I can capitalize on way more than just personal lines sales and some small commercial..." - Eric A.

"As a captive State Farm agent I was only able to offer my clients one option. I seldom felt comfortable knowing my clients would be better off with another agent who could offer choice. Pacific Crest Services has solved this issue for me. Their strategic approach has allowed me to become an insurance broker where I can now offer my clients better coverages at better rates with carriers that make my business very profitable." - Chunky N.

Contact Us

Have questions or need more information?
Contact us today!

Contact us

PCS Insider Blog

Looking for Industry knowledge? Go the the PCS Insider Blog for Insider news. 
The Profitability of Independent Insurance Agencies

The Profitability of Independent Insurance Agencies

Independent agents often have higher earning potential due to the ability to work with multiple carriers and offer a broader range of products. Additionally, independent agents typically earn higher commissions on the policies they sell compared to captive agents, who may receive a fixed salary and lower commission rates.

bottom of page